Chao Garden, Sexy Female Voice in the menu, main theme by Crush 40, crazy storyline, various characters and 2d artwork. That's all I need!

I would like to see:
— Shiro Maekawa as the main writer
— strong plot
— rising level of darkness and seriousness from the start to the end of the game
— at least six playable characters with their own storylines and gameplay styles(not counting superforms)
— character development
— serious Eggman without sidekicks
— Yuji Uekawa as the main designer, designs are back to the SA2 style
— Jun as the sound director, leading a team of the most talented compositors
— songs playing during the levels, like in SA2
— new chracter song themes
— main theme by Crush 40, which also plays in the final battle
— Ted Poley and Tony Harnell
— main villain, who is not a god or a demon
— spindash and boost are both included
— power-ups
— chao-gardens
— multiplayer with lots of characters and levels
— TVs or capsules with bonuses, shields
— character customizing
— SOAPSHOES BEATCH
— new useful and interesting characters (like Tikal, Maria, not like Chip)
— a lot of easter eggs and links to the past games
— adventure fields
— a lot of interesting missions
— Super Sonic in normal levels and adventure fields
— cool bonus features (Marble Garden or Lava Reef in 3D, or something like this)
— extras (concept arts, etc)
— no bugs pleez
— coming out for PS3, Xbox360, Wii, PC, 3DS.

Sry,for bad english

PS, Народ, мне кажется что для англоязычных топиков нужно сделать свой под-форум, иначе будут проблемы с навигацией.

- Massive hub worlds/adventure fields
- Nearly endless sidequests for the hub worlds, being able to see hidden cutscenes and getting lots of rewards
- Darker, deeper, more complex storyline
- Perfected alternate gameplay, like being able to soar through the skies with or without the Tornado.
- Tails being able to run by Sonic again and not having to use his mech
- Give Amy a more important role and have her more distanced away from Sonic to be able to work on character development.
- Knuckles having a Beat-'Em-Up style gameplay in addition to treasure hunting
- Return of Metal Sonic who, this time, will actually stay by Eggman's side, as well as the return of Mecha Sonic, therefore protruding the possibility of a Metal/Mecha Sonic team
- Shadow having his SA2 personality again
- Bigger, longer, more difficult action stages with alternate paths to either get to the end or find gadgets/goodies
- Have a health gauge instead of *just* using rings.
- Return of the Chao Gardens with online capabilities
- Moderate amount of characters; enough that they can focus on character developments without stealing the spotlight from the more important characters.
- Actual movesets for Sonic and the others. The constant homing attack at the enemies for Sonic is getting a bit hackneyed. Switch it up a little and give Sonic some cool moves.
- More variety of enemies, some being more difficult than others, which then you could use various movesets to destroy the harder ones.

I could go on forever...

- New theme song for each character.
- Main theme by Crush 40.
- Complex and serious plot with minimum of plotholes.
- At least 6 playable characters, Eggman among them.
- If there are to be new characters, I want them to look like normal mobians/furries/call it whatever you want. No overgrown chaos like Chip or Wisps please.
- Tails' gameplay similar to one from SA, or something new. Cyclone was nice, but only once.
- Also something new for Knuckles, not only searching for the Emeralds.
- Return of Big the cat.
- More than one storyline (different storyline for each character would be nice, but I won't mind Hero/Dark/Last stories like in SA2).
- Chao Gardens with new types of chao.
- Character vs. character fights on big and twisted platforms.
- Powerup system.
- Light and occasional humor without cola and underwear.
- Final battle between Super Sonic, Super Shadow and some huge creepy monster.
- Variety of missions.
- Characters retelling the past events when continuing the game after exiting.
- Drawn arts, not rendered ones.
- Several CG cutscenes.
- An opening cutscene accompanied by the main theme song.
- Sonic and Nights pinball.
- Space! Outer space!

And of course:

P.S. Кстати, на Цисе crystallize подал дельную мысль. Почему бы не создать тему навроде "STH2006, SH и SU - не СА3"? Насколько я понимаю, на западных форумах это основной аргумент СА-хейтеров.